Buy now or buy later? That is the question. No doubt Sin City, which takes three of comic artist Frank Miller’s graphic novels and brings them to incredible life, is one of the most stylish and memorable films of recent memory, maybe ever. The cast (Bruce Willis, Jessica Alba, Rosario Dawson, Benicio Del Toro, Clive Owen, Mickey Rourke and more) is unending and terrifically talented, but it’s the dedication to Miller’s masterwork – both in the script and the unprecedented visual style – that makes the somewhat disjointed film such a rich good time.

Here’s the catch, though: A remixed DVD is forthcoming, and you just know it’s going to be packed with extra goods as well. Here, you get the film and very little more. Makes a great rental if you want to see what the buzz is about, but fans of the film should hold out for the definitive edition.

Extra: Behind-the-scenes feature. See you ’round Christmastime, special edition.

Grade: B