Aimee Mann’s Second Annual Christmas Show brought an even balance of songs from Mann’s 2006 Christmas album with her more famous songs from her expansive library. The star-studded, two-hour show included guest performances from Grant Lee Phillips, Jackson Browne, Amos Lee and the quirky, awkward, but always entertaining Nellie McKay.

Accompanying Aimee on stage for most of the show was her humorous co-host Paul F. Thompkins. Mann also screened a very funny short film, which had an all-star cast including Ben Stiller, John Krasinski and Will Ferrell, who jokingly mistook her for Jewel.

The sold-out crowd ate up every minute and was rewarded for their cheers as everyone came back on stage for a Christmas medley encore.